My first application was incredible! I was really looking forward to this product because trixies signature eyeliner. I was praying for non runny, hyper pigmented, and the pen itself had good integrity.
Unfortunately it dries out very quickly, and the edge of the pen is already deteriorating. It wasn’t as pigmented as I hoped, but it doesn’t run or fade once it’s on!! It just takes a lot to apply.

I’m sorry, I wanted to love this desperately. I’m an advanced amateur at eyeliner. I wear liner mostly on the weekends when I go out with friends. I’ve been looking for something to replace my wet and wild liner that smudges when I even think about crying.

Sadly this Trixie Cosmetics liner is just not it for me. It dries quickly which leads to it being extremely difficult to build on— especially when I’m trying to get the perfect small/medium, sharp wing. I’ve tried to use it 5+ times thinking I just needed to adjust to a different formula but each time I just get frustrated and usually end up wiping it off. The pen gets streaky, it pulls on the lid and dries very shiny. Also I can ~feel~ that I’m wearing liner, like it feels tight on my lid when it dries.

I bought two because I was convinced it was going to be my new go to. But the first pen I opened is basically already dried out.

I love this product more than any other liquid pen liner. What I love is that the tip is stiff, so it doesn’t spray ink when applying, like some do. Even though it’s a solid tip though, the ink still comes out nicely and has good coverage! 100% recommend.

I've been wearing liquid eyeliner since I was 15 (in a casual daily wing) and I've tried several drugstore and high end liners over the years. I was hoping to love this one since who makes better cosmetics than a drag queen?!

While the formula holds up in terms of wear, application is streaky, the pen pulls on the lid and its hard to get a good sharp wing. The pen often tugs at your eye, leaving spotty application and you have to go over it at least twice to get a good opaque black. I've only been using it a month, and the formula seems dry already. I have to supplement with another eyeliner to get a perfect wing.

Disappointing too as I live in Canada so the conversion + shipping :( I thought it would be worth it! I even bought two!

Doesn't smudge, crack or irritate my sensitive eyes & skin. Will literally never buy another liquid liner.